We do not,however, regard it as throwing helpful light on the question of principle before us. The case was decided by Pillimore on the basis that D and G were "in truth and in fact ... the promoters and vendors" {see at page 1~2) and therefore owed a personal duty to disclose to W Ltd the secret profit that they had personally made through C Ltd on that company's sale to W Ltd , failing which they were accountable to W Ltd for the profit